I got some bright green paper sacks from Michaels. I printed out a picture of a creeper, cut its face out with an X-acto knife to create a stencil. I positioned the stencil on the bag and colored in the creeper face. Voila! Minecraft treat bags!
The kids were so stoked! I couldn't believe that they all knew what a creeper was. The treat bags were filled with little stuff I found from Michael's, and a couple little candies :)
For the cake, I took a picture of a creeper to Raley's bakery. They had actually just made a creeper cake the week prior! I couldn't believe it. They had a better picture than I did. They used that edible photo paper to create this AWESOME creeper cake! I couldn't believe how good it turned out.
I got Haylie a few little Minecraft goodies, including this Minecraft night light and bracelet from Hot Topic:
Hot Topic is the only store that I could find a decent amount of Minecraft gifts. See more at this Hot Topic website.
Here are some other great Minecraft birthday party ideas I have come across on the interwebs: